A Petroleum Group debate voted overwhelmingly against the hypothesis that the Silverpit Structure
(North Sea) was caused by meteorite impact. Dawne Riddle reports.
Science, as we all know, is not a democracy and being popular is not the same thing as being right. However if the majority view counts for anything, then a recent debate at the Geological Society has indicated that the less glamorous ...
This page contains discussion related to Keller, Adatte & Stinnesbeck's article, The Non-Smoking Gun. The more recent items in the discussion are to the top of the page. Go to Discussion page 2 for aubmissions after 22.12.03. If you wish to contribute to this moderated on-line discussion, please email the Editor.
Wider issues remain elusive
From Andrei Ol'khovatov, Moscow (posted 22.12.03...