Product has been added to the basket

Dinosaur Eggs in my Garden?

'Flowstones' - a calcium carbonate deposit formed by the flow of water highly charged in calcium carbonate

Q: I am a South African citizen resident in Midrand, between Johannesburg and Pretoria. I live on a small holding and came across some unusual shaped rocks in the garden. After some physical inspection and references on the internet, I am convinced that these are dinosaur eggs and specifically Hadrosaurus eggs. There are three eggs in total and according to a map on the-web, (National Geographic) there have been 2 findings in this region besides the other 197 in the world. Are they dinosaur eggs?


From Mr Norman Venn (June 2009)

Reply by Dr Phil Manning

The objects do not appear to be dinosaur eggs. They exhibit a distinctive concentric structure which suggests they were formed by deposition from water. In some you can see a distinct central straw-like structure, which is also interesting and uncharacteristic of fossil dinosaur eggs – as of course is the fact that they appear to be rounded only at one end. The structure of the laminae looks rather porous – almost like tufa.

What this suggests is that these objects are a form of “flowstone” – a calcium carbonate deposit formed by the flow of water highly charged in calcium carbonate. In other words I think they are probably stalagmite – though whether they formed on the roof or on the floor of a cavern remains uncertain. The straw suggests a roof (thin stalactites are often hollow centrally) but their mature rounded shape is more typical of something formed on the cavern floor.